"Can Life Compete" -- Strange Horizons
I agree with a lot of what he says--even though I've never played WoW. Similarly, I found a group of friends on the Internet, and by talking to them, learned social skills that were applicable to that thing called "real life".
Admittedly, I did have a couple of quibbles with some of his points. In my experience, it isn't just adults who'll make light of internet friends and socializing--a lot of teenagers that I know also make these arguments. If I were to draw a line between people who "get it" and people who don't, I don't think it would be an age line. It would be between so-called "extroverts" and "introverts".
These teens who don't understand internet friends are usually averse to using the Internet for socializing beyond, say, Facebook and Myspace. This isn't a bad choice; it is perhaps wiser than diving into the depths of the Internet (in some ways; worse in others).
. . . but if you're a pre-teen, or a teenager, and you're lonely and you don't know anyone else who likes the things you like, if you're baffled by how to socialize, sometimes anonymity can be a shield. If you mess up (and this is the important part),
no one will care. No one knows who you are. You can be someone else tomorrow. Different personality, different way of doing things--depending on the site, different clothes, different hair, different gender.
It's a freedom. It's a deliverance.
And, gradually, you learn who you are. You know that you're the kind of person who says
this when that happens, you're the kind of person who does
that when this is going on. You know what you can do, and what you can't; what you will and what you won't.
I'm very fond of my Internet friends. I've known a lot of them longer than I've known my 'real-life' friends, and I know that without the people whose real names I don't even know now, who are an avatar and a made-up name, I wouldn't have the friends whose names I do know. Who I can hang out with real life, who I can whisper jokes to in class.
Some people don't understand this. Some people can't.
On LJ, obviously, some of this is self-evident. But if this journal is my soapbox, then this is what I'm standing on it to say. Because this is why I am who I am. Because this is why I am.
Edited To Add: I believe life can compete. If I didn't, I wouldn't be here, under my real name, and I wouldn't have friends in real life. I do think there is something real life can give us that virtual life can't, but I think that both are necessary.